Sunday, March 7, 2021

Comparing the Trajectories of the Snider-Enfield and Martini-Henry Rifles

Military shooting is quite different from target shooting in several ways.  Precise targeting is less important to the soldier than to the target shooter; any hit on an enemy soldier is likely to incapacitate the enemy, and that is usually good enough.  Moreover, the soldier rarely has as much time to aim carefully for a perfect shot.  Thus, musketry manuals of the Nineteenth Century were focused on teaching soldiers to hit somewhere on an enemy as quickly as possible.

In order to make such hits it was important to understand the trajectory of the bullet being fired so that a soldier could adjust his aim properly.  In this discussion, we will examine and compare the trajectories of the Snider-Enfield and Martini-Henry rifles based upon information taken from the 1870 and 1879 Musketry Manuals respectively.

The Snider-Enfield Rifle

Distance

Greatest height

First Catch

 

Margin for

 

First

 

of trajectory

Cavalry

Infantry

Cavalry

Infantry

graze

yards

feet

yards

yards

yards

yards

yards

100

4 '6"

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

180

200

5'

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

280

300

7'

Thro'

220

Thro'

135

355

400

11'

300

350

140

90

440

500

15'

420

465

100

55

520

600

23'

570

585

45

30

615

700

32'

670

685

40

25

710

800

44'

780

790

30

20

810

The Martini Henry Rifle

Distance

Greatest height

First Catch

Margin for

First

 

of trajectory

Cavalry

Infantry

Cavalry

Infantry

graze

yards

feet

yards

yards

yards

yards

yards

100

4'6"

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

205

200

5'

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

Thro'

285

300

6'9"

Thro'

205

Thro'

155

360

400

8'9"

285

345

165

105

450

500

12'

410

455

130

85

540

600

16'6"

530

565

100

65

630

700

20'9"

645

670

80

55

725

800

26'9"

750

775

70

45

820

Remarks

The calculated height for cavalry forces is 8 1/2 feet, that for the infantry is 6 feet.

The rifle is 4 1/2 feet above the ground at distances to 300 yards; beyond that distance, 3 feet above the ground; the reason for this difference is that at ranges up to 300 yards the soldier was taught to fire from a standing position, while at longer ranges he was taught to fire from a kneeling position.  The object hit 3 feet above the ground at each distance.

N.B.: The first catch and first graze are given in divisions of 5 yards to assist the memory, hence are only approximations.                                                      

Definitions

Distance is the setting on the rifle's rear sight.

First Catch is the first distance at which a round will hit either a cavalry or infantry soldier in the head at that sight setting.

First Graze is the distance at which a round will hit a soldier's feet at that sight setting.

Margin is the distance between "First Catch" and "Graze" at that sight setting.

Point Blank is the point at which the bullet's trajectory crosses the line of sight for any given sight setting; also known as "far zero" today. 


Looking at the diagram above, the first soldier (far left) represents the “First Catch” range; the middle soldier represents the “Point Blank” for that sight setting, being three feet above the ground; and the third soldier (far right) represents the “First Graze.”  The Margin is the distance from the first soldier to the third.

Now we can compare the two weapons:  If we set the sights on our rifles to 300 yards, then in the picture above the First Catch for the Snider is at 220 yards and the First Graze is at 355 yards, with a Margin of 135 yards.  The maximum height of the bullet’s trajectory would be 7 feet.

For that same 300-yard sight setting on the Martini-Henry, the First Catch would be 205 yards, and the First Graze would be 360 yards, with a Margin of 155 yards (20 yards wider than the Snider). The maximum height of the bullet’s trajectory would be 6 feet 9 inches, showing a trajectory that is just slightly (3 inches) flatter than that of the Snider.

If we set the sights on our rifles to 600 yards, then in the picture above the First Catch for the Snider is at 585 yards and the First Graze is at 615 yards, with a Margin of only 30 yards.  The maximum height of the bullet’s trajectory would be 23 feet.

For that same 600-yard sight setting on the Martini-Henry, the First Catch would be 565 yards, and the First Graze would be 615 yards, with a Margin of 65 yards—more than double that of the Snider. The maximum height of the bullet’s trajectory would be 16 feet 6 inches, showing a trajectory that is significantly (6 feet 6 inches) flatter.

The Margin is particularly significant in these figures because it represents the width over which a shot fired at a man would hit an enemy soldier somewhere for each given sight setting.  The wider the Margin, the more likely a shot is to hit, and for the Martini-Henry, the Margin is slightly wider at every sight setting, reflecting the flatter trajectory of the round.

Neither manual specified which specific mark of ammunition was being referenced, and the ammunition for both rifles varied somewhat from mark to mark which could change these figures.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Where to buy Hugh Knight's Books

It occurred to me that it would be useful to have a single linked page that I can give people to show them where to get all of my books.  I ...